17.1 C
Athens
Σάββατο, 2 Νοεμβρίου, 2024

Xi Starts Third Term Facing a Bitter Intellectual War

Περισσότερα Νέα

- Advertisement -

By

Tom Hancock

- Advertisement -

The People’s Economy

The beginning of Xi Jinping’s third term in power has been marked by a bitter intellectual war between advocates of state ownership and planning,  and those touting private businesses and markets.

The public debate among senior economists centers on the merits of a return to a Mao Zedong-inspired “people’s economy.” It’s witnessed otherwise-mundane news items about rural cooperatives and public canteens, features of the Mao-era economy, suddenly going viral online.

The debate underlines a widespread uncertainty in China about where the nation is headed under Xi. And that itself is a drag on an economy already in the doldrums due to the pandemic and a housing slump.

Those on China’s “left,” including so-called Neo-Maoists who are nostalgic for a centrally planned economy, have been facing off against those on the “right” who’ve supported the private sector since at least 1992. That’s when Deng Xiaoping endorsed the ambiguous formulation that China is a “socialist market economy.”

Private Sector Pessimism

Measures of Chinese private business confidence have fallen this year

Xi continued to use Deng’s slogan at the Communist Party congress last month. He asserted the importance of private companies and advocating reforms to increase the role of markets in the economy. He also called for stronger state-owned companies and “common prosperity,” which is seen as a leftist slogan.

The spark for the current iteration of the debate came a few weeks ahead of the congress. That’s when a video of veteran agricultural scholar Wen Tiejun calling for a “people’s economy,” interspersed with footage from the 1960s, began spreading online.

Some elements of Wen’s proposal, such as boosting self-reliance in technology and supply chains to preserve sovereignty, are in line with Beijing’s policy. But his call for more emphasis on public ownership is what set off the fireworks.

“Xi Jinping’s heightened discourse on economic security and ‘common prosperity’ have sent a signal to intellectuals like Wen Tiejun that there is an opportunity to nudge the policy discussion in the direction of China’s socialist roots,” said Jude Blanchette, author of a book on China’s neo-Maoists.

One popular online article compared the supporters of the “people’s economy” to “antiques crawling out of the grave of history.” Prominent economists like Ma Guangyuan of Peking University and Ren Zeping, formerly of Soochow Securities Co., also bashed Wen’s proposal.

The left fired back. While the debate might scare the private sector, that only reveals its “guilty conscience,” an article on prominent Neo-Maoist website Utopia proclaimed.

Weighing in after the party congress was Jia Kang, a government adviser linked with China’s finance ministry. China’s online debate has become “polarized” and “irrational,” he said in a speech. Attempts to deny the role of markets in the economy are “extreme and unacceptable,” he added.

He criticized Wen and his supporters for downplaying the contribution of foreign investment and trade to China’s development. The Communist Party settled the debate over markets in 2013, saying they should play a “decisive role” in allocating resources.

China's Standing Committee Members Of The 20th CPC Central Committee Meet With Press
Xi JinpingPhotographer: Kevin Frayer/Getty Images AsiaPac

Jia was following up on a line of criticism from Li Xiaoxi, a former director of economics at one of China’s top state-run think tanks, who emerged from retirement to call Wen’s proposal “worrying.”

Even talking about a return to 1950s-style economic policy will damage China’s international reputation and undermine private business confidence within China, Li said.

That’s crucial: private business confidence in China is at a low ebb, according to independent surveys. As a result, private investment is slumping too. The threat of sudden lockdowns under the “Covid zero” policy is the main factor, but the debate doesn’t help.

And these issues aren’t just resonating with intellectuals.

An article calling for strengthening China’s system of “supply and marketing cooperatives” —state-owned companies that buy and sell goods from farmers in rural Chinese areas—was taken by many casual readers to signal a return to Maoist communes. With lockdowns this year, local governments have been directly distributing food to citizens, and reports about “community canteens” went viral.

It was quickly pointed out that the canteens were a single-province initiative, and while the cooperatives have always been a part of China’s rural economy, they aren’t going to replace private retailers. Even so, the virality of the articles arguably underlines the widespread uncertainty.

China’s state sector share of GDP has stabilized since the late 1990s

Source: Andrew Batson, Gavekal Dragonomics

Note: “SOE” refers to state-owned enterprises

It’s possible Xi could be puzzled by the resurgence of this debate. The contribution of the state sector to GDP has remained largely constant under his rule, at least up to the pandemic, according to research by Andrew Batson of Gavekal Dragonomics.

And the party last year released a landmark “historical resolution” that re-affirmed that key Maoist policies such as “people’s communes” were a “mistake.”

“While much of Xi’s rhetoric is to the liking of leftists, after 10 years in power, he has demonstrated himself to be more State capitalist (with a capital s) than a true socialist,” Blanchette said.

One universal feature of China’s intellectual war is that everyone seems to feel like a victim. The tone of economists like Jia Kang suggests they feel somewhat under siege, while a response to the agricultural cooperatives debate posted on Utopia suggested the left feels defeated, too:

“I can see this kind of crap almost every few years. Speaking honestly, I am looking forward to something really happening,” the article read, referring to previous calls for nationalization of the private sector. “In fact nothing happened. Instead of robbing private businesses…a bunch of debt-ridden private companies were rescued,” it added.

In the absence of a direct response from Xi, that’s the closest we can get to a litmus test for now: as long as both sides are unhappy, the party’s ambiguous compromise between state and market is probably continuing as before.

bloomberg.com

- Advertisement -

ΑΠΑΝΤΗΣΤΕ

εισάγετε το σχόλιό σας!
παρακαλώ εισάγετε το όνομά σας εδώ

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

Ροή ειδήσεων

ΣΧΕΤΙΚΑ ΑΡΘΡΑ

Taiwan detects 6 Chinese military aircraft, 9 vessels around territory

Taiwan's Ministry of National Defence (MND) reported Chinese military activity near the island on Tuesday and said that by 6 am (local time), six...

China Tries to Blot out Tibetan Criticism of Mining Firm’s Damage to the Environment 

Chinese censors are trying to prevent people from viewing posts that allege severe environmental damage in Tibet caused by sand mining. A young Tibetan man...

Protests erupt in Balochistan as citizens demand justice amid rising violence

Amid ongoing atrocities and lawlessness in Balochistan, a protest took place in Buleda as residents rallied for the immediate arrest of the killers of...

Chinese armed forces are not as strong as they seem, according to experts

China is seen as a formidable power due to its robust economic growth and military expansion in recent decades, but if experts are to...

ΔΗΜΟΦΙΛΗ ΑΡΘΡΑ

Αμπελόκηποι: Γόνος ευκατάστατης οικογένειας ο 36χρονος που διαμελίστηκε στη γιάφκα – Είχε συλληφθεί μαζί με τον 31χρονο στη Γερμανία

Γόνος ευκατάστατης οικογένειας επιστημόνων που μαζί με τον 31χρονο μηχανολόγο – μηχανικό είχαν προσαχθεί και σημανθεί στη Γερμανία για επεισόδια σε πορείες είναι ο...

Αμπελόκηποι: Οι χειρόγραφες σημειώσεις «ξεκλειδώνουν» τις έρευνες της Αντιτρομοκρατικής – 5 κιλά εκρηκτικής ύλης εξερράγησαν

Σε πλήρη εξέλιξη είναι οι έρευνες της Αντιτρομοκρατικής για την έκρηξη αυτοσχέδιας βόμβας στο διαμέρισμα στους Αμπελόκηπους καθώς ήδη ταυτοποιήθηκε ο νεκρός. Από τα αποτυπώματά...

Aμπελόκηποι: «Μεταμφιεσμένοι» τρομοκράτες ετοίμαζαν εντυπωσιακό χτύπημα στην Αθήνα – Βρέθηκαν σχεδιαγράμματα

Νέα διάσταση στις έρευνες της Αντιτρομοκρατικής δίνουν τα ευρήματα απο νέες εφόδους που έγιναν σε τρεις οικίες και ένα όχημα των ατόμων που σχετίζονται...

Διάσταση απόψεων ανάμεσα σε μεγάλα ειδησεογραφικά δίκτυα! Πρίν ή μετά τις αμερικανικές εκλογές η απάντηση του Ιράν;

Οι New York Times, επικαλούμενοι τρεις αξιωματούχους που γνωρίζουν τον πολεμικό σχεδιασμό του Ιράν, ανέφεραν ότι η επίθεση θα γίνει μετά τις 5 Νοεμβρίου...